A key member of the House Financial Services Committee has asked the
General Accounting
Office for a report on the costs and benefits of mandatory
pre-closing home inspections on properties purchased with
government-insured financing.
The study, Rep.
Doug Bereuter, R-Neb., said in his request to Comptroller General
David Walker, should provide policy options for lawmakers to consider
to promote and protect the interest of both home buyers who use loans
backed by the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) and taxpayers who
must bail them out if they get into trouble.
Independent home inspections have become the norm in recent years,
according to a recent study by the National Association of Realtors and the American Society of Home
Inspectors which found that 77 percent of all recent home buyers
hired a third- party inspector to examine their homes prior to
completing the purchase.
Of those, moreover, 81 percent had a contingency placed in the
contract for the inspection and 79 percent attended and participated
in the exam.
But the NAR-ASHI survey did not breakout the differences among buyers
who use conventional funding and those who resort to FHA financing.
And that is huge, says ASHI President John Ghent, an inspector from
Trumbull, Conn.
FHA buyers "typically" don't hire an inspector because they can't
afford or don't want to spend the extra $200-$400, Ghent explains.
"They're getting the bottom-line loan they can get," so they usually
are stretched pretty thin.
But in addition to cost, many confuse the mandatory appraisal with a
home inspection, a mistake that has been compounded by the Department of Housing and
Urban Development's insistence that appraisers report defects they
spot when they make their valuations.
But an appraisal is not nearly as complete as an inspection. And the
inability to cover the high cost of repairing unforseen or unknown
problems is a major reason buyers default on their mortgages.
Ghent recently inspected a foreclosure that was being purchased by a
relative. While the appraiser said he didn't see any problems, Ghent
found just the opposite. "The place should have been torn down," he
says. "The difference between what they do and what we do is night and
day."
ASHI, which has been urging Congress to examine the risks uninformed
home buying decision pose for consumers and federal housing programs,
also believes such a requirement would go a long way toward preventing
such fraudulent acts as property flipping in which a rundown house is
purchased at a low-ball price and resold at a much higher figure after
a few cosmetic repairs are made to mask major problems.
"In many of these cases, there has been no home inspection," says ASHI
Executive Director Rob Paterkiewicz. "Our feeling is that an appraiser
won't catch it when a guy spray paints a distressed property (to hide
defects) but a good home inspector will."
Rep. Bereuter asked the GAO, the investigative arm of Congress, to
examine several key issues:
* The extent to which inspections could protect buyers by identifying
defects that would affect the value of their homes.
- The extent to which the cost of inspections would influence buying
decisions, and how cost issues could be mitigated through FHA
financing charges.
- The extent to which mandatory inspections could protect the
elderly, parents with young children, undereducated buyers and other
populations considered particularly vulnerable.
- The extent to which the lack of inspections place the FHA loan
programs at increased financial risk, and the correlation between
foreclosure and inspections conducted prior to closing.
Rep. Bereuter also has asked the GAO to look into the extent to which
a buyer's choice of a particular inspector may be unduly influenced by
real estate agents who might steer them to someone who isn't as
thorough or may pay a referral fee for sending business their way.
According to the NAR-ASHI study, nearly seven out of ever 10 buyers
chose their home inspectors based upon the recommendations of a real
estate agent.
For more articles by Lew Sichelman, please press
here.
Related Articles:
Can
FHA Appraisals Double As Home Inspections?
HUD
Cancels Termite Checks In Five States
HUD
Names Names: Lists Appraisers By Defaults
Confused?
Who's Confused?
HUD
Pulls Offending Web Page, Claims Posting Unapproved
FHA Buyers
Get New Home After Finding 181 Code Violations
AGENTS: Newsletter
Plus -- the perfect way to stay in touch with your clients and
prospects..
The Financial Wire is Here!
Attention Mortgage Brokers, Lenders and Real Estate Professionals.
Homerun.com has just completed development of a monthly on-line
personalized newsletter for you to e-mail to your clients and
prospects. The
Financial Wire is a must for all Mortgage Professionals serious
about growing their business. For more information, CLICK
HERE
© Copyright 2001 Realty
Times. All Rights Reserved.
Republication or redistribution of Realty Times
content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of
Realty Times . Realty Times shall not be liable for any errors or
delays in the content or for any actions taken in reliance
thereon.
